Glass cliff or breakthrough: four questions that tell you which one you're looking at
On a Sunday evening, the board chair reaches out by phone. For six quarters the division has been losing money, the previous two leaders were both women, and both were gone within eighteen months. The position is yours should you choose it: a bigger title, a $90,000 raise, a seat on the executive committee, and a mandate that, on careful reading, means "fix what two predecessors could not, using the same funds and the same board." You are 53 years old. For five years you have been getting ready for a responsibility of this magnitude, so you know exactly why it has landed on your desk at this moment. Your reply is due to the chair by Friday.
Whether you have what it takes is not in question here. The issue is whether this is a cliff or a breakthrough, and from the outside the two look the same.
Choice one. Accept the role as it stands
The risks are plain to anyone looking at them. If the division cannot be turned around, you become the third name in a row, and that sequence is what colleagues recall. Organizations seldom wonder why three presidents in succession struggled. They start looking for the fourth, who typically arrives with more money and more room to make mistakes. A small Russell Reynolds sample suggests, though it is too limited to be conclusive, that female chief executives served an average of 5.2 years against 8.1 years for their male counterparts. Brief stints of this kind tend to be systematic rather than coincidental.
Choice two. Turn it down
Walking away carries a cost that people can plainly see. Positions of this scale do not open up every year, and "she declined" is a story that gets repeated across the Queen City's business circles. You preserve a spotless record, but you may also be giving up your single chance to prove you can run something that is losing money. At times a steep drop is just a drop. Other times it is the difficult assignment no one else wanted, and whoever takes it earns the recognition.
Choice three. Accept on your own terms
You agree, but with conditions, put in writing before you sign. A defined runway, a named board sponsor, a budget line that your predecessors never received, and an eighteen-month success measure that is more than just "profitable." The risk is that you may hear no, and a no to reasonable conditions is one of the most valuable answers you will get all year. It tells you they wanted a familiar face on the door, not an actual turnaround.
What seasoned leaders advise
Leaders in and around Charlotte who have taken on a cliff job and come out intact tend to ask four questions first.
Begin here. What did the previous two leaders say about their departures themselves, instead of what the board chair reported? Call them. They will tell you.
Next up. What has changed since then? Should the truthful reply come down to "you," treat it as praise, not as a strategy.
Then comes this. Who on the board shares ownership of this result with you? If nobody in the room can point to who that individual is, nobody will back you up once the first quarterly numbers fall short.
Finally. What does success look like, in writing, at eighteen months? Should the board fail to commit its expectations to writing, it cannot judge you fairly, though it will judge you all the same.
The conclusion
The decision rests on the answer to question one. If the last two were set up to fail and only the name on the job has changed, decline, or push for renegotiation until something real shifts. If something meaningful has changed, accept, but get it on paper with a sponsor. Breakthroughs can look like cliffs with a budget attached.
Your choice at the polls
What would your reply be? Accept it, decline it, or accept it on your own terms. Cast your vote below. Next week we will release the findings, together with the question the majority of you said you would raise first.