What she thought was the end of her career, and what came after

Let's name her Vivian. She isn't a real member or client of ours; she's a composite. She is 55, a chief operating officer in the Charlotte region, and forty minutes into a board session that is going poorly when her voice catches on the word "layoffs" and her eyes well up.

The layoffs aren't the cause. It's the eleven months behind them: a father in hospice, alarms at 4 a.m., and a director across the table who has asked, for the third time, whether operations "has this under control." She does have it under control. Her grip on it has held so long that her fingers have started to cramp.

Twelve pairs of eyes are fixed on her across the table. She has maybe four seconds before someone offers a kind word, and that kindness will only make things harder. What she chooses to do in those four seconds is the real dilemma.

Option A: Say sorry and push on regardless

She says "sorry, give me a moment," sips some water, and moves on to the next slide. The drawback is that the apology casts the tears as a mistake, and the room now has permission to see them that way. She spends the following week wondering what the chair thinks, because she apologized before she had any idea.

Option B: Step away for a ten-minute pause

Saying "let's take ten," she rises and walks out of the room. The drawback is that a recess called by the person who was just crying is one everyone understands the reason for, and she returns to a room that has had ten minutes to talk about her. The advantage is real, though. When she returns, she has steadied herself and can complete the presentation in her own way.

Option C: Acknowledge it and continue

She tells the room, "This has been a rough year for this team, and we can all see it." "I'm going to keep going." That is all she offers: one clear line, with no apology and no explanation attached. The drawback is that some directors will remember that sentence longer than the figures. The advantage is that she has put a name to what everyone saw before anyone else could.

What veteran leaders advise

Women who have run Charlotte boardrooms for years are far less alarmed by this than Lydia is. Their view is that crying is seldom what causes trouble; it is the apology that does. Whoever seizes a moment in a room tends to set the direction everyone else follows. Treat it like a disaster and so will they. Treat it like weather and, for the most part, so will they.

They also bring up a point that is harder to hear. The standard is not even. A man who gets choked up over layoffs is "human." A woman is "emotional," and likability research has repeatedly found that the same behavior earns a different label depending on who does it. That is no reason to hide. It is a cue to shape how the moment is framed.

Across a sample of 7,500 women in Deloitte's 2025 research, roughly three in ten, or 29%, said their mental health was in poor shape. None of the women seated in that boardroom are shielded from this. Some have been Lydia.

The judgment

In our composite, Lydia chooses Option C. As the meeting wraps up, the chair tells everyone, "That was the most candid update this board has received in a year," and asks the director who raised the questions to submit them in writing. It surprised her. It shouldn't have. Most chairs in the region have endured worse, and the thing they recall afterward is who pressed on.

Everything hinges on whether you can deliver the line without hiding an apology inside it. If you can, say it. If you can't yet, take the break.

Ballot paper

A, B or C: which would you have chosen? Mail your response to your chapter, and we will print the results next month. If you have walked in Vivian's shoes, we would love to hear from you.